… one of the great values of metaphors is the variety of ways they can be employed and how they can open up an otherwise sealed perspective.
Recently I was browsing at a book display and happened on a copy of The Mirror and the Lamp by M.H. Abrams, first published in 1953. At the heart of this work is an account of a shift from understanding art as mimesis (copy) to art conceived as expression. The mirror suggests that art reflects the world while the lamp invites us to understand art as expressing something of the human person taking us beyond what meets the eye. These metaphors speak to the question of whether the artist (and everyone else) is passive, simply receiving impressions of the world or active, contributing to shaping the world as we know it. The former tends to focus on the senses where art reproduces what is seen, while the latter is inclined look to emotions or ideas that are projected through art. While the mirror has been a key image for science and its relationship with nature, the lamp metaphor loomed large during the early days of the Romantic Movement in the nineteenth century.
The romantics advocated for a view of art that would bring new vitality to the merely mechanical world which was the legacy of some Enlightenment thinkers. The metaphors of mirror and lamp are rich and I would like to suggest a different application than that found in Abrams. I am thinking about the trends, values and ethos of the prevailing culture. How is it that art relates to these? Humanity is deeply embedded in culture, influenced at every turn by the style, morals and ideas of the time. In our world we are subject to swift changes which pressure us to leave the familiar behind and opt for the latest. It is, I think, more common to find artists who mirror back to us the spirit of the times, a spirit internalized and often accepted uncritically.
There is value in this to be sure but there is also need for lamps that will shed unmasking light on the thinness of so much of what constitutes the spirit of the age. This leads me to wonder about art done by members of the Christian faith. It is a standard responsibility of those who are Christian to “discern the times”. It is much easier of course to join with the flow of cultural life and leave the difficult tasks of discernment, critique and challenge to someone else. Mirroring can be exercised not just in mainline culture but also in our sub-cultures.
Art can serve the role of simply reflecting back what we already hold to and so reassure us (perhaps falsely) that all is well. Art practiced as lamp might enable us to better negotiate our way in the dark spots of contemporary life. Art will not save us, but it may be able to help us to see more clearly. I don’t wish to suggest that we must choose one of these metaphors over the other. What I have said suggests that lamp may offer us more than mirror.
But one of the great values of metaphors is the variety of ways they can be employed and how they can open up an otherwise sealed perspective. Both mirror and lamp are images used to describe the scripture. As mirror it aids us in seeing ourselves, disclosing what we may otherwise have missed entirely. As lamp it assists us in lighting a path for the complex journey in which we participate. Likewise art can bring self awareness and new light. Poetry, story, drama and image all are able to contribute to giving us a deeper grasp of who we are and who we ought to be. This same theme is taken up by British author Nigel Forde in his fine book The Lantern and the Looking-glass. Let me offer here an adapted quote from the end of the book;
“We must continue to tell our stories, to explore our experience of those vast abstracts such as love and death and mercy and sacrifice and forgiveness and redemption in concrete [art] that can shake the mind and heart. For, in the end, there is nothing else worth talking about. [Human] relationship to the universe, to God, the actual compared to the ideal, is the stuff of all comedy and all tragedy, and the Christian voice should echo through [art], through the nations memory, as loudly as any other.”